NEW figures obtained by the Observer show that many local councillors fail to attend over half the committee meetings.

Attendance figures show that of 233 meetings held between 14 May 2008 and 16 March this year to discuss important council issues councillors only attended on average around 34 each year.

Heywood Township councillor Peter Rush came top of the class attending 68 meetings, closely followed by the new mayor, Councillor Keith Swift, on 61.

While it’s not necessary for every councillor to attend each meeting, Councillors Robin Parker – who was the previous mayor – Elwyn Watkins and Mark Birkett attended less than one a month.

And Middleton councillor David Murphy, who revealed 18 months ago that he was dividing his time between his Spanish apartment and his home town of Middleton, has attended just three meetings.

Councillor Wera Hobhouse commented: "The Lib Dems have been calling for Councillor Murphy to do the honourable thing and stand down from council for nearly two years now after months of Labour letting him off the hook.

"While the Costa councillor suns himself in Spain many of his constituents in Middleton continue to struggle to pay their bills because of Labour’s mishandling of our economy. This is simply unacceptable.

"His attendance at only three council meetings in a year is made even worse by the fact that when he does choose to fly in for a meeting he only ever stays long enough to sign his name in the attendance book."

But it wasn’t just Councillor Murphy who has been something of a stranger to meetings at the Town Hall with Councillor Birkett only managing to attend seven meetings, blaming his many absences on trying to juggle his working life training to be a commercial pilot with council commitments.

He said: "This is a tricky old manoeuvre. It’s not always easy to combine working with being a councillor – a lot of council meetings are held during the day.

"Most of the time I’m quite happy to go to a council meeting, but most of what I like to do is be involved with case work in the Kingsway ward.

"Basically, the situation for me is that I was on the council, the Township committee and Manchester Airport committee and as far as I know I have attended all but one of those meetings.

"But obviously my position is that it’s not always easy, depending what your job is. I will continue with all the casework, but I don’t sit on as many committees as other people have. I have been attending all the meetings I possibly can."

The leader of the Labour party, Councillor Colin Lambert, recently moved a motion demanding councillors attend all meetings or lose their allowances.

He said: "Councillor Murphy was removed from the Labour group. The focus, though, should be on all councillors' attendance.

"His attendances can be matched by Councillors Elwyn Watkins and Mark Birkett, who have also been absent. Councillors should be attending all meetings or they should not be paid their allowances."

Councillor attendances:

COUNCILLOR
NO. OF MEETINGS
P Rush
68
K Swift
61
M Sharif
59
S Emmott
55
D Brophy-Lee
54
L Murphy
53
D Mulgrew
51
G Cozens
50
Ted Flynn
50
M Bruce
49
T Bailey
49
R Clegg
48
C Wardle
48
B Todd
45
I Davidson
43
J Beswick
43
M Holly
42
F Ahmed
41
P Evans
40
Wera Hobhouse
39
A Dearnley
39
M Rowbotham
38
M Boriss
36
R Jones
36
B Kerslake
35
J P Burns
35
T Linden
35
L Robinson
35
C Akram
34
Jane Gartside
34
P Maguire
33
P Clegg
33
James Gartside
33
A Godson
33
D Whittle
32
A McCarthy
31
P Williams
29
D Clayton
27
William Hobhouse
26
P Davison
26
Pat Flynn
26
A Coric
25
N Mahmud
25
D Martin
24
M Fitzsimons
24
C Lambert
24
A Metcalfe
24
L Thirsk
23
P Colclough
23
J Darnbrough
23
A Abbott
23
J Ashworth
22
I Ahmed
22
A Taylor
20
Z Ali
19
I Khan
13
R Parker
11
E Watkins
  9
M Birkett
  7
D Murphy
  3


Most recent user comments 4 of 4

1 Show  25 | 50  per page

   Could I ask why, of the two councillors with poor attendances, is there only one Councillor who has been removed from the politcal group that he won the seat under? Is it because the Labour Group disapprove of non attenders. Yet the Lib-Dems are not bothered?, and will allow anything.?Have not taken action against Councillor Mark Birkett, who has not been seen in The Kingsway ward for over 12 months.
James Allan Whitehead
28/06/2009 at 22:01
Offensive or Inappropriate?
   With regards to this article can I say that since January 09 to June 09 I have attended 59 meetings plus many more individual ones as well relating to my role as a Councillor for this ward. I have questioned the figure of only attending 22 in the past twelve months as that is not a true reflection to my attendencies. Some I will say that through working I have not been able to attend but have always sent my apologies. I have never missed a meeting that I get extra responsibilty for! Councillor Jean Ashworth
Jean Ashworth,
24/06/2009 at 21:28
Offensive or Inappropriate?
   These figures are rather less meaningful than they might be without a note of the number of meetings on which each elected member supposedly serves.

Can you try again showing the number of meeting each member is supposed to attend and the percentage attendance?

Obviously members of the cabinet or executive are expected to attend far more meetings than others and get far greater pay as a result of that. You need to tell us the % attendance.
Chris Paul, Manchester
24/06/2009 at 13:10
Offensive or Inappropriate?
   Would have been a good article if you could have shown what expenses each councillor had been granted during the same period. Do they get a simple attendance allowance - or is it more?
MPs gravy train, UK
24/06/2009 at 09:50
Offensive or Inappropriate?
1 Show  25 | 50  per page

Add Your Comments